I keep getting the app login screen even with a correct username and password
This happens when your website user account is not connected to a directory entry in the Church Admin plugin.
Thankfully that is easy to fix in one of two ways
Method 1 Edit the directory entry
Edit the person’s directory entry. At the bottom of the screen it will look like this.
If they already have an WordPress website account then you can user the dropdown menu. Otherwise type in a username – the plugin would normally use firstnamelastname adding a number if necessary.
Then click Save Details
Method 2 Create user accounts for everyone that needs one.
Clicking on Church Admin>People>Create Users will bring up this screen to begin creating accounts for all the entries that have email addresses stored.
The choice is why member types you want to include.
Then click Create Users